Discussion in 'Article Discussion' started by Tim S, 14 May 2007.
Which is exactly the reason why this was bound to happen.
as with anything created by man it will be corrupted. I just hope there isnt a huge backlash on the producers who obivously never wanted this especaially with how german is jumping up and down or killspie games
"Show me on the doll where the Second Life avatar touched you"
And I suppose Counter-Strike players will be arrested for virtual-murder?
I reckon deathmatching is a lot less creepy than pretending to be a three year old so that people can pretend to sexually abuse you...
lol - are you sure you dont want to retract that comment!!!
as above, this was bound to happen, took longer than i thought, but bound to happen. Where theres a will, theres a way!!
fixed in edit
I agree: Death-matching clearly a game to most people. The other is just sick from any angle.
What's that loud bleeping noise??
Oh yeah, its my sarcasm detector...
The 'age play' thing is pretty wierd, but it can have numerous parallels drawn to the likes CSS.
Virtual mass murder and terrorist bombings are acceptable but virtual child abuse isn't?
I personally think its correct the way it is.
ie, child abuse, whether virtual or not is wrong.
CSS, while depicting violence, is much more acceptable IMO.
Originally Posted by CardJoe
I reckon deathmatching is a lot more creepy than pretending to be a three year old so that people can pretend to sexually abuse you...
Yes, I do want to retract that comment. It wasn't sarcasm, I just got my sentence mixed up. Meant to point out to Capnpedro that deathmatching is much LESS of an issue. I've edited the post to show what I acually meant.
Sorry again, simply used the wrong word (more/less)
If it was purely a virtual pursuit then why the hell not, let the weirdo’s role play in their virtual world so long as that’s where it stays.
However, if as the report suggests real life abuse is being bought and sold in this virtual setting, then those responsible should be perused by the highest authorities and have their balls chopped off.
Thanks for the clarification / correction Joe.
even as "pretend" it's sick - I agree with the feelings behind the rest of your post though.
Interesting news story, relevant to me, as I joined second life around a month ago. The various escorts and strip clubs are quite funny really, I don't see the attraction in a cartoon person. As for the age play, I guess if they are consenting adults who are role playing, then it is their choice. I don't agree with this form of role play as I think it's obviously sick. The distribution of child pornography has far wider implications, as this unfortunately involves children being abused in real life by real adults, and should be dealt with appropriately. There are retailers who will sell adult baby clothes etc in real life for consenting adults to use...should this be stopped? As for second life...after a month I'm pretty bored, the lag sucks, its just the same stuff everywhere
People seem to forget that Second Life is just a fancy chat room. And as long as chat rooms have existed, people have used them to share illegal material as well as act out their fantasies with like minded people. This is nothing new. It wasn't 'bound to happen' simply because it already has been happening all around the world ever since the internet began.
The only significance that this story has is that in Germany, depictions of child abuse whether real or not are illegal. It may well mean that someone will try to ban the game in that country. That of course is the important issue we should be discussing.
this was bound to happen...... but anyway this is pure and unadulterated stupidity in a jar with razor blades and TNT.
no surprise at all.
ok, here is one statement we should all agree with,
''Child abusers should be hurt badly, very badly!!''
end of story.
Meh, file it away with the "war on drugs" and the "War on poverty" and (my favorite) the "Global war on terror". Where there is a demand, and I think it's pretty clear there is a huge demand for child porn, there will be a supply.
Just to clarify a point for some of you here (whose prejudicial comments bely nothing more than closed minded knee jerking).
Age PLay is a form of roleplaying that may or may not have a sexual component to it. It is, for many, a paraphillia much like shoes, baloons, clowns or (for a large group of you here) the latest offering from the Nvidia Graphics Labs.
Age play, between consenting adults, has catagorically nothing to do with "real children" or "real child abuse" and to group them together is not only an irrational and illogical statement, it is also extremely offensive. It is the same mentality that claims "all homo-sexuals are child abusers".
Child abuse is an extention of a need to control or exert power over a vulnerable individual (hence the moniker of abuse). Age-play is simply that, PLAY between consenting adults.
So if you are going to react to something of whichyou have no understanding then the argument to arrest CSS players for virtual murder, WOW players for Virtual Warcrimes or RTS players for virtual membership of the Nazi party.
Separate names with a comma.