I'll give a game a **** score if it deserves one, but people generally only poo-poo things like this because they don't personally like them - which is not a valid reason. Farming Simulator 2011 is not trying to be a AAA FPS, it's trying to be a Farming Simulator - and if you're out looking for a farming simulator game then this one is an OK. It's not great, but it's not truly terrible either; merely run of the mill and average at best. Thus, 5/10. Compare it to something like Winter Voices (http://www.bit-tech.net/gaming/pc/2010/09/24/winter-voices-avalanche-review/1), which sets out to be a story-driven and philosophical RPG but which fails utterly at it. THAT'S a bad game and, as such, it gets a bad score.