Fair enough - I've literally never heard of him before and so this was just my first impressions of him. I understand that he may be having problems with his hardware when he mentions about the HOTAS deadspot but I don't have any issues with mine. Also his comments about replayability seem odd when you've got multiplayer and even just practice mode which is fun. As for his ripping apart the rebel characters - I don't see how they're any worse than any other npc's in any other game. Maybe he was hoping for characters he recognised but then you'd have the die-hard star Wars fans screaming about canon etc. Maybe I'll look at some of his other videos, maybe not.