Hi all, I am in the process of upgrading my son's pc - he's into video editing/animation etc having posted previously on the CustomPC forum I wanted some further advice on the choice of motherboard. I was originally going for the following upgrade components: Q8200 4GB Corsair PC2-6400 (800) Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 Pro 750 GB Samsung Gigabyte GA-P31-ES3G However, I would like to have a motherboard with firewire support rather than using his current pci card so was looking at changing the motherboard to a Gigabyte GA-EP43-DS3 This brings the build cost to around £335 (£20 more the original) Any comments/advice on this board would be appreciated Thanks in advance
Didnt catch your post on cpc. what you have chosen looks good. What graphics card you going to use for this build?
He's currently using a Nvidia 9600GT but I will probably upgrade this for him around Christmas when funds allow
I this is the thread I think it is then I may I posted on it before the forums got lost into cyberspace. Actually, I'm not sure... It might help if you could say how much you have to spend on the whole upgrade. Depending on what you will be using it for, I'd either switch the CPU down to an E7400 (for gaming) or spend a bit more (~£10) and get a Q6600/Q6700 if he'll be using CPU intensive multithreaded apps. Either way, I don't think the Q8200 would be the best choice. I assume you'll be overclocking this lot, as that'll also affect what would suit you best.
My original thread was about updating my sons aging PC - he's into animation and movie making/editing. His system at the moment comprises of: Asus P5NSLI Nvidia 570 MB 2048MB Ram 250GB HD E6400 CPU Windows XP Media Center I had a budget of £200-250 but added a new hard drive to the build too. I doubt he will be doing much if any overclocking as music and animation/video are his main interests. He does some gaming so a cpu which would do it all would be good too. After several posts in the old thread I decided to go with the upgrade outlined in my first post, but then my son asked about direct firewire connection as he has been having problems with the pci board he uses - so I started looking at a new motherboard option - GA-EP43-DS3. I am a complete noob to upgrading/PC building and my son will be doing most of the build himself due to my aging sausage fingers. So will be guided by any advice given. Thanks again
That P31 + quad core won't go together that great. It'll work, but you'll be somewhat limited. I would stretch for the P45 Biostar board - it's not too expensive, and the CPC guys love it. Personally I like the Gigabyte P45 UD3R, but it's again £110 and probably out of your budget. The P43-DS3 should be pretty good too - CPC might have covered it recently... Maybe check out the MSI P45 Neo3? Apparently it's their best seller (according to MSI PR I talked to on Friday), but I've no experience myself. I wouldn't get Freezer7, I'd get an Akasa personally, and the Q6600 or E7500 and overclock them Or, an AMD Phenom II X3 720 Black Edition with Biostar 790GX board. That should overclock to 3.4ish easily nice and stable, but I'd recommend a meatier cooler.
Thanks for that - the P45-UD3R is over my budget so I guess I'll stick with the GA-EP43-DS3 as the other boards do not have firewire. Although he does play games I think he needs to stick with a core quad for his rendering work. I will also switch to: Akasa AK-965 Intel CPU Cooler Q6700 Just puzzled is it purely overclocking that makes the Q6600 better than the Q8200 and are Core Duo better for games the Core Quad?
For games, it depends how many processors the application is able use. For instance, Crysis will take all 4 cores if they're available.
Thankyou - guess I'll stick with quad core then Thanks all for advice - is the scan insurance "scansure" worth it or is just a gimmick to get more money?
The Q8200 has a lower multiplier, so it needs a high FSB, to get decent a overclock, something that cheaper motherboards generally don't achieve. The Q6600 has more cache, but is less power efficient. At stock a Q6600 & Q8200 provide virtually the same performance, however a Q6700 will be faster, because of its higher frequency. One thing to consider is that the Q8200 has SSE4 instructions, which the Q6600 lacks. For multimedia applications such as certain Adobe products, that utilise SSE4 the Q8200 will be faster than the Q6600.
The Q6600 is pretty expensive these days, you can get a Q8400 for £15 less - I think that would be a better choice TBH.
http://www.tekheads.co.uk/s/product?product=608353 http://www.tekheads.co.uk/s/product?product=609544 http://www.lambda-tek.com/componentshop/index.pl?origin=gbase27.3&prodID=B221545 ? Q67?
Using an EP45-UD3R, which can achieve a high FSB, would you still prefer a Q6600 / 6700 over the Q8400, if so why? Thx TT
got a back and forth on another thread about this same subject...good times. assuming that all you care about is speed for speed, then it would depend on your ram. if you have high freq. ram, the q8400. i've run build benches, and unless the q8400 is giving up 400 mhz or more, it is a better performing chip and the better performance per dollar bargain than the q6600/6700.
That is interesting, the benchmarks I've seen comparing the Q8200 (2.33 GHz) to the Q6600 (2.4 GHz), are pretty close, in fact the Q6600 is faster most of the time, probably due to its larger cache. Of course if you use apps that utilise SSE4, the Q8000 series win. What type of overclocks are you getting from the Q8400, and on what board.
i've hit over 3.5 several times. once on an abit ip35 pro, another on an asus p5q i believe. i'd have to get back to you on the others. the q6600 was the darling child for a long time. when looking at price for potential performance it was a sure bet. but prices have been creeping up here, and the q8400 is cheaper, just plain making it the better buy. haven't even looked at the q8200 prices yet tbh.