I've finally blown up my Creative Gigaworks S750 I might try and get it fixed, other wise I'm looking for a decent replacement, any ideas? The things that need to sound good are Battlefield2, 2142, BFBC2, and obviously BF3 at the end of the year - I already have a Creative X-Fi Gamer.
It depends what you want out of them and ultimately what you're prepared to pay. I'm waiting for my Gigaworks to die so I can buy the Bose Companion 3s or 5s (depending on the best deal on the day). I use mine as a jukebox just as much as gaming speakers, so the Bose win for my needs.
Its purely gaming! As for cost - as much as i'd love the best of the best, I can only sell 1 kidney (!), do it needs to be reasonable, no more than £150 I think I'm thinking i should stick with 5.1 (not that I ever really noticed the 7.1 it currently does!)
I'd like to be of any need but I use speakers only to listen to music. Basically I'm saving money to build a pair of Back loaded horn or Open bafle (I'm still hesitating). Bluesky makes great 5.1 system, but this is expensive.
If it's purely gaming, just get a standard set of pc speakers for general web browsing (£20 or 30 would be plenty) and invest the rest in a decent set of headphones or gaming headset - and not a 'surround' headset. You'll still get positional audio through a stereo headset via your sound card trickery and because it's right on your ear, you'll hear more of the all important sound cues, like footsteps etc, than you will through a 5.1/7.1 speaker setup. For the ultimate headphone/headset argument, search for posts by Docodine...